Movie Review: 12 Dates of Christmas (2011) - DWC Magazine

Movie Review: 12 Dates of Christmas (2011)

ABC Family’s 12 Dates of Christmas takes the classic time-loop trope and dips it in a vat of holiday glitter. While it doesn’t break new ground, the film delivers a dose of yuletide magic, self-reflection, and romance wrapped in a tidy bow. Starring Amy Smart and Mark-Paul Gosselaar, it’s the cinematic equivalent of your favourite holiday sweater: familiar, cosy, and just a little cheesy.

At its core, 12 Dates of Christmas is  Groundhog Day meets gingerbread latte and is about second chances—12 of them, to be exact. Amy Smart plays Kate Stanton, a control freak with a laser focus on rekindling her romance with her ex-boyfriend, Jack (Benjamin Ayres). Enter Miles (Mark-Paul Gosselaar), a widower with an easygoing charm and a perfectly arched rom-com eyebrow. Their blind date sets the stage for a quirky, heartfelt love story... after Kate gets pepper-sprayed. (Yes, really.)

But just when Kate thinks she’s found closure—or a potential future—life (and a mysterious dose of Christmas magic) hits rewind. Forced to relive Christmas Eve a dozen times, Kate begins a journey of self-discovery, learning lessons about love, letting go, and why maybe you shouldn’t ignore your stepmom’s heartfelt invitations to dinner.

Kate isn’t your typical rom-com heroine. She’s relatable precisely because she’s imperfect: a little self-centred, a bit obsessive, but ultimately well-meaning. Amy Smart plays her transformation beautifully, balancing the snarky with the sincere as Kate moves from controlling her circumstances to embracing life’s chaos.

Meanwhile, Mark-Paul Gosselaar’s Miles is a Hallmark hero done right. He’s sweet without being saccharine, quirky without feeling forced, and just grounded enough to counterbalance Kate’s frantic energy. While Miles’ character arc isn’t exactly robust, his easygoing nature serves as the catalyst for Kate’s growth—and their chemistry makes the predictable romance feel like unwrapping a gift you actually wanted.

The supporting characters, however, are more garnish than substance. Jack, Kate’s ex, is there to remind us why she needs to move on, while Kate’s stepmother, Margaret, offers brief moments of emotional depth that feel underserved.

Beneath the mistletoe and predictable rom-com beats lies a surprisingly poignant message: life rarely goes as planned, but it’s never too late to rewrite your story. Kate’s journey is a metaphor for the detours we all face when chasing happiness. Her time loop isn’t just a plot device; it’s a reminder that sometimes we need a few tries to figure out what—or who—truly matters.

The movie also lightly champions mindfulness, encouraging both Kate and viewers to savour the present. Miles, with his ability to find joy in the small moments, serves as a quiet beacon of this message.

Chemistry That Clicks: Smart and Gosselaar share a natural rapport, making their romantic arc both charming and believable.

Lighthearted Humor: From accidental pepper spray incidents to Kate’s awkward attempts at “fixing” her timeline, the comedic moments add levity.

Holiday Vibes: Snowy streets, twinkling lights, and carolers galore—this movie absolutely nails the festive aesthetic.

Plot Holes? Oh, We Have Those! The time-loop mechanism is never explained. Is it magic? Karma? A particularly sassy ghost of Christmas Eve? You’ll never know.

Underbaked Subplots: Kate’s relationship with her stepmother and the quirky side characters feel like missed opportunities for emotional depth.

Predictability: If you’ve seen one holiday rom-com, you can pretty much chart this one with your eyes closed.

12 Dates of Christmas doesn’t try to reinvent the sleigh. It’s sweet, predictable, and unapologetically cheesy—but that’s part of its charm. For fans of festive rom-coms, it’s the kind of movie you throw on while wrapping gifts or sipping mulled wine, content in the knowledge that everything will work out in the end.

Will it change your life? Probably not. But will it leave you with a smile and maybe a few warm fuzzies? Absolutely.

If you’re a fan of holiday classics like Groundhog Day, Love Actually, or The Holiday, 12 Dates of Christmas might just become a guilty pleasure in your festive lineup. And really, isn’t that what Christmas movies are all about?

So, grab a blanket, pour yourself some hot cocoa, and let Kate’s journey remind you that even if you’re stuck in a loop, there’s always time to make things right. Sometimes, all it takes is 12 tries—and a little Christmas magic.

Related Posts

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.